I dont think anyone so much "wrote him off" (except the ones that write everyone off the first time they drop a pop fly or strike out) I believe he can be an effective mlb'er off the bench,part time starter.Itd be great if he could become that lead off hitter you are talking about.Prob is,he struck out in a ball,aa ball and now at the mlb level.lead off hitter hes not.just A very nice hitter in the 7 hole,bat off the bench.
he def has his place here,just not what you think he could be ,imo.