I judge women based on makeup. One of my favorite song lyrics is from Brand New: "I got a twenty-dollar bill that says no one's ever seen you without makeup. You're always made up."
That's how I look at celebrities. Most actresses look normal without makeup. There are exceptions and before she became a drug addict, I Lindsey Lohan was hot without makeup. I have a thing for light haired gingers/strawberry blondes though. I think they pull off the no makeup look really well.