if he hits like miguel c which isn't likely, the glove won't matter

I'd bet good money that Miggy will give up more runs at 3rd directly, and indirectly as a result of marginal inability over a real 3rd baseman, than he will score.

Ditto for Fielder.

Having a guy with NO glove in the field is a much bigger problem than you think it is. And in the case of Fielder and Cabrera, a ginormous problem.

Remember Giambi? This is worse, and doubly worse again.

Verlander's not going to be winning any Cy this year with a couple of ham-fisted Sumo wrestlers on his corners. Both are DH's, both are worse than having no-one on 1st or 3rd.

"I'd bet good money that Miggy will give up more runs at 3rd directly, and indirectly as a result of marginal inability over a real 3rd baseman, than he will score. "

What's good money to you? I want some of that action!

If Cashman made it through the hilarious "Joba Rules" he may survive this. I hope not though. This team cannot afford another stupid move from the GM.

I like Campos' numbers and he's 6'4", 18 years old, and not obese. But I notice a lot of back peddling amongst Cashman and his supporters regarding this trade.

When the trade first happened, Pineda was a future #1.
Then he became the solid #2 that would compliment CC.
Then Cashman says, Pineda, with work, could develop into a #2.
Next it was "we only need him in the rotation so he can develop."
Now it's "there's still hope with Campo." LOL

You're not thinking straight. You can't evaluate a hitter after 7 at bats. That's just plain silly.

So sad that some fans are okay with the Yankees turning into the Atlanta Braves. Talk about lowering the bar. LOL

So, the GM is supposed to know that a player will develops tendinitis in spring training? Great logic.

Before ANY games are even played and you are calling it a failure? Silly, silly fair weather fan.

Fans like you would never question a GMs move even if the GM was Zippy the Chimp, because you know your place as a mere loyal fan. So you repeat your mantra; They know everything, and their decision making is impeccable. I'm happy you're content.

Wether Pineda pitches up in NY this year is completely irrelevant. Had the trade not been made, Montero probably would be in the same boat.

That's the ownerships job, not mine. It's their money, not mine, so they have to make that call.

No troll will EVER answer that question.

"it's their money, not mine.".

That's all you need to repeat to yourself. It's good advice so you should follow it as well.