• Welcome Guest
Toronto Blue Jays

Welcome to the Toronto Blue Jays.
Before posting, please review our Message Board Guidelines

    • Seattle wanted Lawrie for Pineda
  • 4/5/12
  • gsnarls

There is not a player in baseball I would trade Lawrie for.

-

Hard to argue there. So incredibly valuable. No one to replace him at third except double E.

You'd have to offer me probably a Cy Young caliber SP and a serviceable DH for me to even think about it.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • connorp


Harper
Strasburg
Moore

off top of my head.. no on Trout.. would have to put though into others.. that is with considering salaries..

  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • connorp

"Complete conjecture. Rejected outright. "

With the benefit of hindsight, it may prove to be very telling in the case of Pineda.. hedging bets on breakout year and disregarding previous scouting reports..

  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • noxage

"disregarding previous scouting reports"

You mean like Lawrie being a poor defender with only gap power? Breakouts happen.

  • Reply to this Message
Message 80355.38 was deleted
  • 4/5/12
  • gsnarls
Good point re salary. I'd not trade him even for guys like a Kershaw or Hernandez + a good bat if the salary difference was $40-50 mil per year. Course, it's just a matter of time before we gots ta pay Lawrie the mega millions, too.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 80355.40 was deleted
  • 4/5/12
  • noxage

"I wouldn't say its 3 >>>, but I'm more of a fan of Teheran than I am of Pineda going forward."

Now that we've actually seen some of the health concerns come to fruition, I agree. At the time of the deal though I wouldn't have.

  • Reply to this Message
Messages 80355.42 through 80355.43 were deleted
  • 4/5/12
  • thehurl
Meyer is a freak of an athlete though. Still doesn't make him have control though...if he gets the control in order he still might be a star. I'd rather have the 6'9" guy with effortless delivery (which is not Meyer), than the 5'10" pitcher who has to use every part of their body with every pitch.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • HASHTAGLOVETHISTEAM

"Lol, Lawrie and another prospect. Right..."

I lol'd too.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • thehurl
I made my opinions of Pineda known all through last year, if without the injury history I wasn't huge on him long term...with me being as high on Montero as i am (I have stated many times last year that strictly as a hitter he'll have a better career than everyone in this or last years prospect lists not named Harper or Rendon and I'll probably admit now that Montero might outhit Rendon) I think this deal will go down as one of the best of all time.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • gsnarls

First I'd heard of these types of comments though. Source Jayson Stark:

"I needed a fresh start. I needed a new team," said Blue Jays third baseman Brett Lawrie to ESPN's Jayson Stark about his trade from the Brewers. Lawrie feels Milwaukee tried to change his effusive personality, though GM Doug Melvin disagrees.


Edited 4/5/12   by  gsnarls
  • Reply to this Message
Message 80355.48 was deleted
  • 4/5/12
  • thehurl
I almost never watch live. I like to have the ability to fast forward to parts where prospects are pitching if I choose so watch away. At some point I'd like to test what happens if two people sign on at the same time anyway...I'm betting that nothing will happen.
  • Reply to this Message
  • To:All
  • 4/5/12
  • gsnarls
Having a hard time finding info on Lawrie's contract. Best I could find was on MLBTR, suggesting that he will be arbitration eligible after the 2014 season. Does that seem right?
  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • noxage

Google "Cotts Contracts"

All of your needs will be satisfied.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • thehurl
Then after that, google COT's contracts.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 4/5/12
  • noxage
Yur dumn.
  • Reply to this Message