We don't have a good team, but position players/offense isn't the problem...it's the pitching.
Without letting a starting lineup play together for a good amount of time, how is he supposed to know what he could have? The offense and defense would likely be even better if Gardy ever settled on his starters...which he never does unless injuries force him to do....like end of 2009 and a good chunk of the 2nd half of 2010.
Tinkering every single game is counter-productive and believing the team isn't that good certainly shouldn't mean you play your substitutes MORE...should mean you play your best players as much as possible and your subs way less...in order to field your best team.
Edited 4/20/12 by ThePuck