"So if you're grading Dayton on the Gil Meche signing, that wasn't a bad signing."
it turned out to not be a bad signing, but it was stilll a risky one. meche was trying to shake the injury-proned" label, and had never established himself as a top of the rotation type prior to coming to kc. in fact, he came to kc from seattle with a career 4.65 era.
the guy just happened to have his best years while pitching in kc. jonathan sanchez came to kc with a better resume than meche, and the royals took a substantially lower risk on sanchez than they did meche.
point being, when you're a team like the royals ..... you have to be willing to take big risks, many times unconventional risks. whether it be trade or free agency, the royals are going to have to take chances on guys with red flags.
sometimes the gamble pays off, other times it doesn't -- armchair GMs be damned.
Edited 7/16/12 by keeno_kc