aptlynamedBuc,
Ciriaco most assredly should have been retained and should have been given the real opporunity to be the Pirate's SS.
I've been saying for a while Hurdle is not inclined to use speed and stolen bases. We have the legs to be effective. Ciriaco represented that strategy. There was a reason Ciriaco made the initial roster that has more to do with his speed. Hurdle did not use him much and when he did he was productive. Whether or not Hurdle may have been eyeing Barmes even last year could have also been a factor in not retaining Ciriaco.
Ciriaco is batting .349 in his time with the Bosox so far. .349!!!!!
He is effectively in the infield, outfield and DH'ing. He has 9 steals in 9 attempts. The Bosox are also near the bottom in MLB in steals and attempts.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/MLB/2012.shtml
Ciriaco is third on the Sox in steals with 9. Pedoria and Aviles have 12 and 11.
The 'Green Light' idea is really more of a theory or conjecture. The way the pitcher holds the runner on and tries to pick him off there is also a matter of execution that probably produces a successful pick off more often than not. Stealing a base is often more successful with an executable strategy.
Yes, it could be random and still be a success. However...............
If you have a lefty at the plate and a man at first, even if it is Ricky Henderson, you could easily tell the runner you are going to swing in front of the catcher on the next pitch . YOU will steal the base. I've seen batters swing on a pitch out to get the man over. When I played ball we worked on strategy like that at the college level.
It is not that Hurdle is not one of the best baseball men we have had since the days of Harding Peterson. He is. However he is also working on many fronts that may be more of his experience.
I'd say the strategy of making every pitch count and the obviously limited success we have had without running crazy is more managable at this point of our voyage.
Mark my words, the Pirates should be and at some point will become reminiscent of the old Gas House Cardinals we have heard about. You combine that missing strategy with the streaking offense we have and the Pirates might dominate.
BEAT 'EM BUCCOS