• Welcome Guest
Houston Astros

Welcome to the Houston Astros.
Before posting, please review our Message Board Guidelines

    • Is Jeff Luhnow the best GM in the national league?
  • 8/6/12
  • Ashitaka
I think the most you can say is the best at building a farm. Given what we've seen, I'm not expecting him to do anything in the future in terms of trading for or signing veterans that will hurt him much, but it would be premature to call him the best after 9-10 months of focusing on one area and one area alone.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 8/6/12
  • Ghick

I think the most you can say is the best at building a farm.
=======

It's too early to suggest even that. The Padres, Diamondbacks, Braves, and Nationals all have great farms that have been built on good drafts and thoughtful trades. Luhnow has to get a bit of a track record -- beyond then handful of months -- before you can objectively say he is the best.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 8/6/12
  • astrohop

"I think the most you can say is the best at building a farm."

Not as long as Mike Arbuckle is alive and well.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 8/6/12
  • Ashitaka
Who is he with now? I didn't realize he was an NL GM, last I heard he was fired from the Royals and I can't remember hearing about him taking an NL GM job since then.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 8/6/12
  • astrohop

"Who is he with now? I didn't realize he was an NL GM, last I heard he was fired from the Royals and I can't remember hearing about him taking an NL GM job since then."

His name is Mike Arbuckle and no, you didn't hear he was fired by the Royals because it didn't happen. He's still there doing his thing. But you are right he isn't the GM so I will change that to Dayton Moore. The man with enough sense to keep Arbuckle.

  • Reply to this Message
Recent Discussions
May Predictions
Latest by Marshall - 5:56 AM
2013 MLB rule 4 draft watch/discussion thread
Latest by greekDBAG - 5:50 AM
5/24 OAK @ HOU
Latest by Marshall - 5:44 AM
Race to First Pick in 2014
Latest by Marshall - 5:31 AM
Chris Johnson is only hitting .350!
Latest by batman007 - 4:39 AM
“This guy is taking a dump. There's no doubt."
Latest by batman007 - 4:38 AM
2013 Minor League Tracker thread
Latest by Ashitaka - 2:34 AM
Jose Veras' logo
Latest by kevinbass - 1:52 AM
On Pace 2013
Latest by jimbo0488 - 12:39 AM
Dieker
Latest by txheat10k - May-24
Powered by Mzinga