Its not unorthodox to bring your closer in a tie game at home and he does not have an out pitch. He only have one good season which was 2010. His career SO percentage ( percentage of all plate appearances ending with a strike out ) at 17.5 % and below .2 % than the MLB average at 17.7 %. His numbers are not that great since he moved in the AL where batters are better than the NL.
"" ERA is inflated because of his pitching in non closer situations...some closer just have trouble pitching in non closer situations. Capps isn't the first or the only one either... """
In save situation ( 14 saves out of 15 games ) his ERA is 3.14 gave up 5 ER, 2 home runs w/ 10 strike outs
In non save situations his ERA 3.75 gave up also 5 ER, 2 home runs with 6 strike outs.
I don't know how you can say that his ERA is inflated.
Then again he is the least of my worries now and its not that we are a contender and we need a good closer.