• Welcome Guest
Cincinnati Reds

Welcome to the Cincinnati Reds.
Before posting, please review our Message Board Guidelines

    • OT: Colts
  • 3/7/12
  • RedsRevenge

Excellent post. I felt from the day Irsay started cleaning house that Peyton's days were coming to an end in Indianapolis. It really is a smart decision overall by Irsay and one that he and Manning made together too a degree.

36 Years old with two neck surgeries and the team in rebuild mode = good luck luck.


Edited 3/7/12   by  RedsRevenge
  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/7/12
  • 6thsense
I think that is exactly what he should do. He is risking major injury if he continues to play. I don't believe any neuro-surgeon would release him to play football again.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/7/12
  • RedsRevenge

Not to mention some of the treatment he received was done overseas because it wasn't performed in the states.

I wouldn't be shocked if he walked away but i think he believes he has something left and will test the waters and pick the best team he can that has a real chance of a deep playoff run.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/7/12
  • 6thsense
I think he has plenty left but the risk of major injury is too great for him to test it.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/7/12
  • scoringposition
I'm sure he'll make sure a team has an incredible offensive line. Heck, they don't even need a running back that runs, just one that blocks.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/7/12
  • 6thsense
That is still too risky. One good blow and it's all over.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 71082.18 was deleted
  • 3/7/12
  • scoringposition

It's definitely a hard choice to make. Baseball was my first and only love when I played and I had a choice: to take a year off and do surgery to get my elbow fixed or hope with better mechanics to fix my throwing motion. I knew I couldn't afford to take a year off so I fought through it and lost anyways.

I'm comparing apples to hog balls a bit here but if he did retire, I'd support his decision to the fullest.

  • Reply to this Message
Message 71082.20 was deleted
  • 3/7/12
  • 6thsense
Your elbow is restricted to one arm. His neck could cause total paralysis if he gets hit just right. Too risky. At least that's how I understand it from the type of surgery he had.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/8/12
  • RolandoRoomes55

I am with you...sort of. If Trent is there ...I would take him at 17...he might be there..that guy is an Adrian Peterson clone. I like the Barron pick at 21 but not at 17.It al depends on who's left on the board. What if they sign Micheal Bush...do you steer away from Trent all together? Jeffery had some off feild problems..I think there are good receivers deeper too. Thats another position that could be solved in free agency, Wayne,Jackson,Manningham,Bowe,Garcon,Larent Robinson...someone with some experiance would be nice..dare I say Mike Wallace.

In a later round, I love the Martin kid from Boise State. He is the real deal too.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 3/8/12
  • RolandoRoomes55

I think he will be headed to Denver myself...I think John Elway knows that Tblow is not the answer. Elway knows what it takes to win in the NFL and Tblow doesnt have it. He will be a one hit wonder....Vanilla Ice for sure.

  • Reply to this Message
Message 71082.24 was deleted
  • 3/9/12
  • RedsRevenge
3 Broncos just tested positive for PEDS. Also, the Colts cut Dallas Clark and Joesph Addai today.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 71082.26 was deleted
  • 3/10/12
  • centre
Manning ends up in Miami or Arizona next season...
  • Reply to this Message