If Scott is working out at Tropicana ... then the handwriting is on the wall ... they're going to re-sign him.
If he can have a whole season hitting like he hit last April ... then I'll admit that he surprised me offensively ... as a DH. HOWEVER ... aside from the 'damaged goods' element of his background that I think will have permanent after-effects ... the singular basis for my objection to him being on this team is that ... injuries aside ... he has NEVER demostrated any proficiency and effectiveness playing any position anywhere ... and I'm just opposed to a DH who can ONLY DH ... plus ... the guy is turning 35 in June! And ... like Molina ... age and diminished ability eliminates him as "a Rays' way" kind of player.
And ... I know his fans will say that he can play first base in a pinch ... BUT ... the guy has NEVER shown any real defensive ability at ANY position, first base or otherwise ... and ... over 798 games in which he's appeared ... he's only played first base in parts of 35 of them! Now ... if he was Mickey Mantle ... fine. DH only! But ... on this team ... with only 12 position players ... I wouldn't want to waste a roster spot on an older guy who can't play defense well ANYwhere on the field.
Plus ... overall ... in his eight seasons and 798 games ... he's hit only .260 ... with an average of something like 15 HRs and 48 RBIs per season. Definitely no great shakes!
Frankly, I'd prefer to take my chances with a DH-by-committee ... along with the belief that Gimenez ... who, as you've said, can defensively play multiple positions well ... will blossom into the kind of DH and VERSATILE player that EVERY team would want! A guy that can hit consistently ... AND ... play multiple positions ... well!
Having a guy like Scott around simply doesn't fit your "how the Rays are built" comment ... young players with excellent defensive skills, good foot-speed, good game know-how, and the talent and ability to play multiple roles and positions.
I'd ALWAYS prefer to take my chances with multi-talented, multi-faceted young guys ... and in this case ... I'd go with Gimenez at DH without any hesitation or second-thoughts whatsoever!