Seems to me, in my day, if you did not do exactly what the coach wanted you
to do, when he wanted it done ... You did not play and even worse they got
someone else to take your place, even if you were better than the guy who
replaced you.
Okay, times have changed ... but the GM or manager with my way or the highway
mantra would only have to send down a few players or release them and that
silliness would stop.
Everyone says it's about the money ... But if that was the case, no one would be
paying guys with barely AA skill sets well over $1 million to play on the show team.
It's all about egos and not wanting to look bad or be criticized by the media.
Take Carlos Pena for example: I would have sent him to low A last year and said
you either learn to bunt and hit the ball to the opposite field or you will rot down
in low A ... He would have got all bent out of shape and said NO WAY.
Then I would have suspended him without pay for the whole season which you
can do IF a player refuses an assignment. You do not have to release them or
put them on waivers ... Only take one example to fix the problem.
But you can easily solve this problem of skill sets. Don't draft guys or sign guys
who cannot get on base, strike out more than once every two games and if it's
a pitcher someone who cannot throw strikes with 3 pitches.
To be a winner in the show, you do not really need any superstars (it helps but
it is not necessary), you need 8 above average position players in all phases
of the game and GOOD pitching. Think SF Giants. They have won with Posey
and without.
It would be easy to win because the other guys would not be as good at the level
of the TEAM. You would win the close games more often than not.
Think about the Rays one run game record from last year ... Beyond the pale of
unacceptable. They could have easily won 5 maybe 10 games more, if Pena and
a few others could bunt and put the ball in play when it mattered instead of being
walking strike outs.
I hear guys saying it's how they play ... their way. I say fine, play with yourself
because you are not playing on my team because our goal is to win games, not
showcase your lack of smarts.