• Welcome Guest
Philadelphia Phillies

Welcome to the Philadelphia Phillies.
Before posting, please review our Message Board Guidelines

    • ANDRE EITHER OVER JAYSON WERTH???
  • To:All
  • 11/12/09
  • BroadStreetBullies
ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Andre Either had 32 COUNT EM' 32 hits against lefties. What a joke.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • joefri
Yeah, not really thinking he deserved it. I would have went JDub over Ethier
  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • dp205

I agree. Ethier was great and so was Werth.

Werth has 36 dingers with 99 Rbis, and an impressive .509 slugging.
Ethier had 31 dingers with 106 Rbis, and an impressive .508 slugging.

Could have gone either way, tho. I like Ethier and Kemp and they both deserve it...I don't want to take away from them, but Werth may have just beat out Ethier in my eyes.

Could you imagine an OF of Werth, Ethier, and Kemp (which they could've had)?

I'm not saying Jay is better than Manny in anyway offensively, but it would have been a lot more athletic for sure.


Edited 11/12/09   by  dp205
Edited 11/12/09   by  dp205
  • Reply to this Message
Messages 85740.4 through 85740.5 were deleted
  • 11/12/09
  • phila98
Well, Ethier did have more hits, doubles, triples, rbis, batting avg and only 5 less hrs. Their seasons were very close.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • BroadStreetBullies
One thing I don't fly with is hitting great at home and being non existent on the road or really not even close to as good. Either hit .307 at home and .238 on the road. 1.103 OPS at home and .703 on the road. Catch my drift? Werth's home and away splits were really good and balanced.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 85740.8 was deleted
  • 11/12/09
  • wildthng88
I love how people take dam RBIs seriously since they are team dependant and why Etheir won it over Werth.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 85740.10 was deleted
  • 11/12/09
  • BroadStreetBullies

LOL @ YOU!

WRONG

Sorry Either hit almost 400 points on OPS lower on the road via at home. Sorry, that is pathetic.

  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • dp205
yeah, if Werth doesn't hit behind Howard, he has a chance for about 100 more RBIs....but he hits behind the RBI king. not his fault. like I said, it could've been any combination. I think Werth should be there, but it's not a rip that Ethier is.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • Sardoodledum
No respect.
  • Reply to this Message
  • To:All
  • 11/12/09
  • nylost
I wouldn't say he was robbed. (actually I would but it's all bias so I won't) It was close. Jay should have came out on top though for certain.
  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • wildthng88
Yeah but I think people look way too much at team dependent stats like Runs scored and RBIs. Like BSB said Ehtier hit an astrociouis way away from LA. That's inexcuseable for a silver sluger.
  • Reply to this Message
Messages 85740.16 through 85740.17 were deleted
  • 11/12/09
  • Eag510

Ooh, sorry. Wrong board. It's ok, here ya go!

<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JbmO1C2hEk

  • Reply to this Message
  • 11/12/09
  • wildthng88
Werth was pretty clutch too. Also Werth is a better fielder. now beat it troll.
  • Reply to this Message
Message 85740.20 was deleted
Recent Discussions
Ask Pettiboner: Are The Phillies This Bad
Latest by ph1llybama - 10:08 PM
4/18/14 Phillies Vs Rockies OFFICIAL GAME THREAD
Latest by sperlific1 - 10:07 PM
The comeback begins.....
Latest by lilsebastian00 - 10:06 PM
OT: New Official Flyers Thread
Latest by fuller12 - 10:01 PM
Minor League Thread
Latest by johhos - 9:54 PM
Dominic Brown
Latest by surviva - 9:40 PM
Who's gone by AS break
Latest by grandpam2 - 9:40 PM
OT: Sixers Thread
Latest by joboggi - 8:10 PM
OT: TV/Movie Thread
Latest by wildthng88 - 8:01 PM
Music Thread
Latest by wildthng88 - 7:40 PM
Powered by Mzinga