What I know is that Bourjos is a strong defensive CF, I'll grant you I don't know much about Gose so you may be right about his defense, but Gose hasn't really played much at the ML level, so honesty I can't make a great case.
I do know that in Bourjos' 2011 season when he played every day, he hit .270 .327 OBP with 22 SB 12 HRs. Thats fine. He is a major league ready outfielder.
Right now Gose seems like a younger Andres Tores. I know its only 166ABs but with a .303 OBP with that kind of speed... this guy should be forced to do push ups every time he hits a ball in the air or swings at ball 4.
Edited Dec-15 by PrayedforBay