Both teams are offering their prospects to us? Which do you choose?
I say D'Arnaud. Outfielders are a dime a dozen. Especially ones who strike out as much as Olt does. Just look at this years crop of FAs - Pagan, Ludwick, Victorino, Ross, etc. Catchers rarely see free agency, especially good, young ones.
Since TOR is more interested in Niese, package him with Mejia and get both D'Arnaud and OF Anthony Gose (speedy, top of the lineup hitter).
Extend Dickey. Then flip Duda, Valdespin and a B+ prospect for OF Shin-Soo Choo.
We have a contender...
1. Gose CF2. Choo RF3. Wright 3B4. Davis 1B5. D'Arnaud C6. Murphy 2B7. Tejada SS8. Niewenhuis LF
No way the Jays are trading D'Arnaud.
If that's offered, take it and run... As fast as possible.