Arod to have surgery will miss the at least part of the season, Murphy's best position is 3rd base.

What do you think we could get from the Yankees in exchange for Murphy?

I'll take Gary Sanchez.

Cash considerations.

Me too lol.

The one reason I wouldn't want to trade Murphy is because I think he is a perfect fit for the Yankees. He hit 23 doubles 3 triples and 1 HR in Citi Field last year, with the ridiculously short porch in right in Yankees stadium that could be more like 20 doubles 1 Triple 12 HRs.

The prime directive states that we never deal with the devil.

That's very true, Murphy would probably slug .600 in that park.

In all seriousness, Phil Hughes is a free agent after this season. I'd be willing to take a chance on getting him a change of scenery and out of the AL East. Look what it did for Burnett.

I would love to rid our team of Murphy. This is the type of player that precludes us from making progress and brining in real talent. A player like Murphy should not the any higher than the 6th best hitter on a good team.

Let us remember, no matter how the Mets have done, most of us think it was a pretty good season if Yankee fans aren't parading in November. We should never do anything to help their cause.

Murphy is an above average offensive player. .292 career average, 50 XBHs a season at 27 years old he is not a star but offensively he is a good player.

well, the Mets and Yankees hardly EVER do trades with each other....that being said, I would expect much more from the yankees than any other team if we traded Murphy. I personally don't want to trade Murphy unless the trade is REALLY helping us in a big way. Murphy isn't that bad defensively and is a .300 hitter with 40 doubles who doesn't strike out much. I think Murphy is SEVERELY underrated.

So yea, the ONLY way I even listen is if the yankees are offering their best prospect(s)

"I would love to rid our team of Murphy."

You're right...his .300 avg and 40 doubles really destroy this team...

They did make a David Justice for Robinson Ventura trade a few years back.

Would you do a Murphy for Brett Gardner deal?

there have been trades in the past...though not many and not that significant

that would be intriguing...if Gardner was healthy

"Murphy isn't that bad defensively and is a .300 hitter with 40 doubles who doesn't strike out much. I think Murphy is SEVERELY underrated"



100% agree.

Mets should get at least 1 GOOD prospect for him. Preferably C or OF.

"Would you do a Murphy for Brett Gardner deal?"


Murphy for Gardner (if healthy) AND C prospect!!

Other teams won't be giving up anything worth what Murphy is to us. They would probably offer a reliever or MAYBE a decent prospect...but that is nowhere near what Murphy is worth. I would want an OF/C of equal value (.300 avg with occasional pop, or a .270 with 20 hrs+, either being cheap and young like Murphy)

no no no no no no no no no

I refuse to see my favorite player playing for the yankees

no no no no no no no no no

Yup.

Let's see what Alderson can come up with. Could surprise us. Like Beltran for Wheeler. Murphy DOES have good value to teams looking for 3B (even 1B) or DH.