Did you see X Paul play LF in a recent game? Guy's LOST. Mediocre bat. Inept Fielder. No HR pop.
No base-stealing threat. All he has is that he's a LH hitter.
Chris Heisey can run circles around XP in OF. Hits as well, or better--with more power. Hustles and is SB threat.
Bruce needs to be platooned alright. But with Heisey. Let Heisey play 2 of 3 series games;Jay 1 of 3 series games.
I still think this was a LaRussa prank. He selected Jay for All Star game. Let him play. So Jay thinks "I Really Am an All Star"! La Russa did that to mess with Bruce's head--and hurt the Reds in 2012.
It apparently worked!
If you Must play X Paul, teach him to substitute for Joey at 1st base. He's a LH guy. Should be able to do it. It's one of the easiest field positions there is. X Paul can rest Joey once per week. And Dusty will still be happy:he has a LH hitter in the line-up(Joey or Xavier) every day.
This Dusty obsession with LH hitters is a form of mental ineptitude--or worse. Dusty seems to think
a LH hitter is More Important than (1) a Reds win, and (2) a guy who can field & run, and (3)
a guy who can do more than hit singles(XPaul). XPaul is a PH--nothing more!