If you believe in the "hot" and "cold" stuff then you must also believe that there are methods to identify when a player is "hot" and "cold".
If you can't identify the pattern then it's random and JP is never really "hot" or "cold" it's just random varation.
However if "hot" and "cold" exist then there has to be a pattern. And maybe the other posters are just one level above you and they've identified the pattern.
So they know that even though J.P. is hitting .320 in July he is actually today entering a cold streak so they want him down in the order.
Or have you identified the pattern?? Do you have proof that J.P. will remain hot for the foreseeable future?? How do you identify when he goes cold??
I mean obviously if J.P. goes 3 for 40 then he's cold. But for the hot, cold pattern to be useful we need to identify it before J.P. goes 3 for 40 so we can hit him 9th for that time period.