Why in the world would we be looking at a platoon of Reynolds/Betemit at 1B when we have a perfectly competent glove (and bat) there already in Chris Davis? His career numbers show he's a good defensive 1B. One bad game this year and now he's not an option there?... but instead we consider 2 guys that are perpetually poor with the glove?
For years we've been looking for a "prototypical", big, left handed power hitting 1B. Now we may finally have him for the first time since Palmeiro left, and we're intent to use anyone but him there.
The only way this makes any rational sense whatsoever is if we're looking to deal Reynolds too, and this Thome acquisition was merely the first stage in a multi-pronged attack. And the time Mark is stealing from Davis at 1B is a (failed) attempt at increasing his value.
The only other explanation = Buck is clueless and/or has something personal against Davis. And I don't want to believe that.