"Exactly. These people seem to, think that if you are the worst team in the game for three years in a row a magic wand is waved somewhere and presto, you're in the WS."
No, but it helps. Look at the Nationals; Harper and Strasburg may very well lead them to that franchise's first pennant this year. You can either draft the talent and get their best years for cheap or sign it and get a few declining years for a bazillion dollars. After another draft or two, along with trading off the final pieces like Wandy we have now, we'll finally have enough depth in the system to where we can stop selling and let a large crop of prospects develop.
Right now, we're still too thin at almost every position to stop the acquiring of prospects any way we can. Schafer has holes, Bogusevic is a short-term solution at best, Johnson won't last, Lowrie will be expensive soon, Castro hasn't shown much, and Norris is the only starter currently in the rotation who has a legitimate chance to be a good MLB mid-rotation pitcher for the next 3-5 years without costing an arm and a leg. Down on the farm, we have some good names, but all of them are either young with significant development time yet ahead of them (and a good chance still to bust), or they have holes and have been inconsistent. Singleton is the closest thing we have to a can't-miss prospect, and he still hasn't shown a lot of HR power and is slumping right now, not to mention he's basically a bat-only prospect. We're not just a few pieces here or there away.
We're not talking about the difference between a legitimate playoff run and a 110 loss season on this thread. We're talking about being willing to win just 65 games and finish in last place rather than win 68 games and finish next-to-last for the sake of getting the very best prospect we possibly can to help us win consistently for years at a time in the future.
Edited 5/12/12 by Ashitaka