Maybe, but I'd still rather have him than Wilson. I also think Darvish's stuff & mentality is a lot better Dice-K.... Build too.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
I like Pineda more than Wilson. Right now. With Pineda's shoulder injury and all. I could not possibly like Wilson much less.
----------------
Nolan rides em hard it's worked for them so far.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
If we make the mistake of confusing good fortune for good logic, then everybody ought to do this. Dusty Baker had a very similar philosophy with Prior/Wood and later with Cueto/Volquez. How did that work out?
The reality is that it's probably got as much to do with a pitcher's mechanics as it does to his workload. A guy with Prior's mechanics probably breaks down, even with a lighter workload. But it probably takes longer than it did.
That said... for all the "Nolan rides 'em" stuff... what homegrown pitcher have they really pushed, in terms of innings?
Holland maxed out at 198 last year, and he's been in/out of the league for 3 years now.
Harrison did 185 after being up/down for the 3 years prior.
Ogando got bounced back and forth from the rotation to the pen.
Feliz closed, now he's starting.
Even Wilson spent a bunch of time in the pen before getting his innings pushed in his late 20's.
For all the talk about how hard these guys are "pushed"... their workloads are pretty conservative.
And their numbers all look amazing because they're padded by 36 games against the A's and Mariners.
What do you think Phil Hughes' ERA would be if he made 15 starts against the Padres, A's, Mariners and Astros? Would you worship the ground he walked on and sign him to a big extension?